
Bois des Iles EDC and Parfum Comparison
Left Arm: Chanel Bois des Iles Parfum
Right Arm: Chanel Bois des Iles EDT
I applied a good sized dab of the parfum, and two very wet sprays of the EDT in an effort to equalize the two somewhat. What I noticed immediately is that the EDT had much more prominent aldehydes in the top notes. The aldehydes also are in the parfum, but are either much less in concentration, or are eclipsed by the strength of the rest of the composition. In the EDT, the aldehydes are very similar to No.5, if not the same. I think I remember reading somewhere that somebody thought BdI EDT was like a combination of No.5 and Coco. I think I can understand this comparison--the No.5 aspect is form the aldehydes, and the Coco aspect is from the spicy undertones, barely perceptible at this stage. In comparison, the spices and woods are immediately present in the parfum, and the small amount of aldehydes gives it a touch of brightness.
I think I really doused myself on both arms. Either that, or the development is slow to unfold. It took quite a while for the aldehydes to burn off (about an hour). In the process, the EDT really blossomed. I smell very ripe peach, brandy, dark rose, clove, vanilla. When I don't try to discern the separate notes, I get the "gingerbread" effect that people talk about. To me it seems more like a rum spice cake, but I suppose that is what gingerbread is, in a way. The EDT is not as woody as the parfum, and it has a bit of that sourness that I noticed in 31 Rue Cambon. Some sweet powder is also starting to come out.
The parfum is almost knocking me out, and so I think future wearings may demand a smaller dab, lol. I actually can still smell some of the aldehydes after 1 hour. But, I also smell a luscious sandalwood, vanilla, clove, dark rose, and only the tiniest hint of brandy and fruit. It does not have the same kind of "fermented" smell that the EDT has, and it is not as sweet at this stage. I don't get the gingerbread association as much, either.
I would classify the parfum as a sultry chypre in the same vein as Shiseido Feminite du Bois. I suppose I would also classify the EDT in the chypre family--only it reminds me more of Dior Dolce Vita, which has family similarities to FdB, but is much lighter in every respect. I definitely also see the resemblance to Coco, now that both the EDT and parfum have dried a bit.
Now, about an hour and a half after application--the EDT is fading. It is wearing longevity-wise as 31 Rue Cambon does. And to be honest, the drydown also smells quite a bit like 31RC, only it is much less sour (a big plus for me). The parfum is still going strong, but is opening a bit more, and the dark floral aspect is more apparent. Still no gingerbread with the parfum, but it has a way to go. I think, though, the sandalwood and vanilla will play a larger part from start to finish in the parfum. In contrast, the EDT dries to fruit, floral and powder, with only a hint of wood.
I wonder which one Luca Turin reviewed in The Guide? I give the parfum 5 stars, but I am not sure I would give the same rating for the EDT. The EDT is almost a completely different fragrance from top to bottom--the aldehydes are challenging, and I am not sure they really "fit" the composition. I really love the soft drydown of the EDT, though....